Warm ochre Victorian house behind a leaf-strewn lawn and sidewalk under mostly bare November trees in a quiet Pennsylvania neighborhood.

Walking Smethport's Mansion District, Hamlin by Hamlin

In 1903, the McCandless Mansion at 905 West Main Street was greatly enlarged. The 2021 Mansion District brochure gives the reason: so the house would "appear more prominent next to her brother Orlo's house, next door." "Her" is Emma Hamlin McCandless, a daughter of the banker Henry Hamlin. The brother was Orlo J. Hamlin, Henry's only son. His house at 911 West Main had been a wedding gift from their father the year before.

That bit of sibling rivalry explains the whole street. Smethport's Mansion District is usually described as a lumber-and-oil showcase, and the money did come from the lumber, oil and railroad boom of the 1870s and 1880s. Walk West Main with the brochure, though, and most of the big houses trace back to one family. Byron Delano Hamlin, his nephew Henry, their sons and daughters, a son-in-law, a grandson and a bank officer all built within a few blocks of one another. Read in walking order, the street works as a family tree.

Start at the Courthouse, Then Byron's Corner

The printed tour begins in front of the McKean County Courthouse and heads west on Main Street. The courthouse is the county's fourth. It was built in 1940 and 1941 to a design by architect Thomas K. Hendryx, after fire destroyed the 1880 courthouse designed by Martin Beebe. Smethport Borough says paper copies of the walking-tour brochure, a joint project of the Smethport Area Chamber of Commerce and the Allegheny National Forest Visitors Bureau, are available at the courthouse and the Visitors Center. The Lumber Heritage Region also posts the 2021 version as a free download.

The family story starts in the 600 block. St. Luke's Episcopal Church at 602 West Main dates to 1891 and is English Gothic. According to the brochure, Henry Hamlin hired William Halsey Wood, already a nationally known architect, to design it, and most owners of the district's homes belonged to the church when it was built. Ross Porter's 2008 tour book describes a square battlemented tower with walls two and a half feet thick, a one-piece white marble altar slab and an oak screen between the nave and the chancel.

Across the street, the 2008 book identifies 607 Main Street as Byron Delano Hamlin's law office and the location of the second Hamlin Bank. Just west of it is the house where the family began, the Byron Delano Hamlin Mansion at 619 West Main. Byron was a state senator and a railroad and land entrepreneur. He and his wife, Harriet Holmes Hamlin, broke ground on the Italianate mansion in 1856. In 1874 he started the McKean & Buffalo Railroad to haul coal for the Buffalo Coal Company. The house later belonged to Melville Gillette. The 2008 book notes a racquetball court built inside the carriage house and the outline of old clay tennis courts east of the home.

Next to St. Luke's, the John Forrest Mansion at 620 West Main is the brochure's next stop after the church and the first in-law house on the walk. John Forrest came to Smethport in 1877 to work in Byron's law and land office. In 1878 he married Mary Hamlin, Byron and Harriet's daughter, and they finished their Victorian Stick home in 1880. The 2008 book titles the entry "He Married the Boss' Daughter!" and notes that the former carriage house behind it is now a separate private residence.

The 700 Block, Where the Neighbors Weren't All Hamlins

Even on the block with the most outside names, the family is present. The State Senator H.H. Redfield Mansion at 703 West Main, a 1900 Queen Anne, belonged to Horace Hamlin Redfield, whom the brochure identifies as Byron D. Hamlin's grandson. His business list ran from regional banks and the McKean County Refining Company to a seat on the board of the Coudersport & Port Allegany Railroad.

His neighbors were not Hamlins. Judge Joseph Bouton served 31 years as McKean County President Judge. His 1905 Queen Anne at 707 West Main had golden oak woodwork by Hyde & Murphy of Ridgway, with wall panels of leather, imitation elephant skin and hand-painted designs. The Charles Sartwell Mansion at 708 West Main is the oldest house on this stretch, built in 1848 to a design by Charles's brother, the Smethport architect-builder Solomon Sartwell. It was remodeled over the years from Greek Revival to an 1890s Victorian Eclectic. In 1910 Scott F. Redfield, publisher of The Boys Magazine, bought it.

The W.J. Milliken Residence at 716 West Main, a Colonial Revival from around 1872, belonged first to attorney W.J. Milliken, who also served as district attorney and school superintendent. The brochure says it was restored with historically accurate paint colors.

The 800 Block Belongs to the Banker

Henry Hamlin, Byron's nephew, started banking in 1863 in what became Hamlin Bank and Trust Company. In 1892 he was reported to be the wealthiest private banker in the United States. His Italianate mansion at 808 West Main dates to around 1860. Across the street, the A.N. Taylor/D.C. Young Mansion at 807 West Main is another Italianate from about 1860. Merchant A.N. Taylor died in 1876. His son-in-law, DeWitt Clinton Young, took over the business and the house, which was known for central heating and several indoor bathrooms with hot and cold running water.

Byron's side of the family shows up again at 820 West Main. Delano R. Hamlin, Byron's only son, was a partner in his father's law and land business when this Queen Anne went up in 1881. His first home is farther west, so the walk passes his second house before his first.

At 904 West Main is the John C. Hamlin Residence, a Colonial Revival from around 1878. John was Henry's younger brother. He opened what the brochure calls the first store devoted only to hardware in 1865, and he was Senior Warden at the Episcopal church, back at 602, where he taught Sunday school for many years.

The 900 Block, Where Henry's Children Built

The 900 block is where the opening story happened, and this is where the brochure has the most family detail. At 905 West Main, the McCandless Mansion was built in 1891 to a design by architect E.N. Unruh. John H. McCandless, who married Henry's daughter Emma, was the priest at St. Luke's when the house went up. Natural gas supplied heat and light, and cherry and golden oak woodwork lined the interior walls. The 1903 enlargement came after Orlo's house went up next door. The house is also home to the Mansion District Inn, which lists 905 West Main as its address.

Orlo J. Hamlin's Queen Anne at 911 West Main dates to 1902. Henry built it as a wedding gift for Orlo and his bride, Mirabel Folger of Geneva, New York. Orlo later took over his father's bank, and the brochure notes hand-carved woodwork throughout the interior.

Another of Henry's daughters lived at 916 West Main, the Rose Mansion, a Victorian Stick from around 1889. Robert Rose married Laena Hamlin there. He was an attorney and agent for the Bingham land estate, the original owners of most of early McKean County, and in 1890 the couple moved to Binghamton, New York. Their stay in the house was short.

The family's reach extends past the relatives. The R.E. Burdick Residence at 1002 West Main, a Queen Anne from around 1900 and another E.N. Unruh design, belonged to Hamlin Bank officer Ralph E. Burdick. He was an early amateur photographer and one of Smethport's early car owners.

Where Delano Started, and Where the Walk Turns

At 1109 West Main is the Delano R. Hamlin First Residence, a Queen Anne the brochure dates to about 1875. Delano married Eugenia McCoy in 1871 and joined his father's law firm the same year. This was the couple's first home before they moved east to 820 West Main.

The last two West Main stops come from outside the family. The Christian Herzog Residence at 1199 West Main dates to around 1905. The brochure says electric wiring on ceramic insulators ran through the house in anticipation of electricity, which reached Smethport only in 1922. The Chester King Residence at 1225 West N. Main, from about 1881, is the walk's example of Italianate eaves on corbels. From there the brochure sends walkers back toward Byron Street and up the hill to King Street.

These are private homes, so the walk is a sidewalk walk. For a quick reference, these are the Hamlin family's West Main houses in the brochure's stop order:

  1. 620, Mary Hamlin Forrest and John Forrest, 1880
  2. 619, Byron Delano Hamlin, 1856
  3. 703, grandson Horace Hamlin Redfield, 1900
  4. 808, Henry Hamlin, circa 1860
  5. 820, Delano R. Hamlin, 1881
  6. 904, John C. Hamlin, circa 1878
  7. 905, Emma Hamlin McCandless and John H. McCandless, 1891
  8. 911, Orlo J. Hamlin, 1902
  9. 916, Laena Hamlin Rose and Robert Rose, circa 1889
  10. 1109, Delano R. Hamlin's first residence, circa 1875

The Bank Is Still on West Main

The family business is still on the street. Hamlin Bank says it was established in 1863 and was the first bank to serve McKean County communities. Its Smethport main office is at 333 West Main Street, a few blocks east of the houses its founder's family built. The Lumber Heritage Region notes that Smethport was the first community designated a heritage community along Pennsylvania Route 6, and that designation is what led to the brochure.

For more than the brochure covers, the walk continues to King Street. The 1875 McKean County Jail building at 502 West King Street has been the headquarters and museum of the McKean County Historical Society since 2003. The Old Jail Museum keeps seasonal hours. It is open Tuesdays and Thursdays from 1 to 4 p.m. in April, May, September and October and Tuesday through Saturday from 1 to 4 p.m. in June, July and August, so a late-November visit is by appointment. The society's office is open Tuesday through Friday from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. Hamlin Memorial Library, which also carries the family name, is at 123 South Mechanic Street. Holiday hours can differ from its regular schedule.

On Thanksgiving week, with family in town and an afternoon free, the walk from the courthouse to 1109 West Main and back is one of the few in Smethport where almost every house has a known builder and a reason it went up where it did. Our Smethport neighborhood page has more on the borough. When December arrives, the town's holiday season moves down to Water Street.

If you own one of Smethport's older homes or are thinking about buying one, the team at Mountain Valley Realty, Inc. can talk through what owning a house with this kind of history involves, from carriage houses to woodwork that has lasted more than a century. Call Now — Talk to a Local Agent.

Work With Us

We listen carefully to understand your real estate goals and work hard to create solutions that make sense for you. Whether you are new to the market or an experienced investor, we have the expertise, proven track record, and resources to help you achieve your real estate goals.

Follow Me on Instagram